Take Ellen White out of Adventist history and the first thing you lose is the glue. In 1844 the Millerites were a scattered, heartbroken crowd. A teenage girl from Maine with visions and very little schooling helped turn that disappointment into a movement with a Sabbath, a sanctuary doctrine and a mission.
You’d also lose the infrastructure. Her counsel pushed a small church to build hospitals, schools and publishing houses on almost every continent. Loma Linda, the vegetarian health message and the Adventist school system all carry her fingerprints. Without her, we might be a tidy little Sabbath-keeping denomination in New England, and nobody would study our life expectancy.
But the honest answer includes the costs. She has sometimes been used as a club rather than a guide. Quotations get pulled from more than 100,000 pages to settle arguments about jewelry, cheese and novels. Church leaders at the 1919 Bible Conference already worried that members treated her writings as infallible, and the debates over her literary borrowing in the 1980s shook many people’s confidence.
She never wanted that role. She called herself “a lesser light to lead men and women to the greater light,” and she meant the Bible.
So the answer is probably different, and smaller. The real question for us is whether we read her the way she asked to be read: pointing past herself to Jesus. When we do, she stops being a weapon and goes back to being a gift.
Head over to Adventist Today for current events, analysis, and opinion on all things Adventist.
