Thursday, November 19, 2026

The Old Days Weren’t That Great Either

Share

The Old Days Weren't That Great Either

People have a way of romanticizing the old days. We talk as if earlier generations of Adventists were purer and better intentioned, as if they had their act together in a way we don’t.

There’s some truth in that. Many of our pioneers sacrificed enormously. They gave up comfort, money and health for a message they believed with everything they had. Ellen White sold her own home at a low price and put the money into schools and meetinghouses in new fields. I honour that. They did their best with the lives they were given.

But that isn’t the whole story. For much of our history, Adventism has been mired in legalism. At the 1888 General Conference in Minneapolis, two young ministers, A. T. Jones and E. J. Waggoner, called the church to a more Christ-centred message of righteousness by faith. Plenty of senior leaders fought them hard. Ellen White pleaded for the message, and years later still called that session “one of the saddest chapters in the history of the believers in present truth.” In 1890 she wrote, “As a people, we have preached the law until we are as dry as the hills of Gilboa that had neither dew nor rain.”

Church politics could get ugly too. In 1891 the Foreign Mission Board asked Ellen White to go to Australia. She went, though she wrote in her diary that she had no special light to leave America. Five years later she told the General Conference president, “The Lord was not in our leaving America.” There was, she said, “so great a willingness to have us leave” that God allowed it, and “those who were weary of the testimonies borne were left without the persons who bore them.”

In 1901 she stood before the General Conference session and said the idea of leaders being “the voice of God to the people, as we once believed the General Conference to be” was past. “God has not put any kingly power in our ranks,” she told them. Two years later she wrote, “We are to have no kings, no rulers, no popes among us.”

So no, the old days weren’t that great. I actually find that encouraging. A lot of us grew up as legalists, and we have learned so much about grace since then. That growth counts for something.

We don’t have to romanticize the past, and we don’t have to believe the future is bleak. With God, we can build an Adventism that’s more generous and more faithful, more open-minded and more determined. I want a church that follows God wherever He leads and keeps finding more life, with the door wide open for whoever walks in.

That’s the kind of Adventism BarelyAdventist is here to champion.

Photo: Unknown photographer, published by Schuler C. Baldwin / Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/?curid=128739788)

Head over to Adventist Today for current events, analysis, and opinion on all things Adventist.

Read more

Local News