Thursday, December 18, 2025

Why Predicting an Adventist Church Breakup Is Short-Sighted

Share

Let’s start where we should: God is in control. Not as a cliché, but as a reminder that the future of the Adventist Church is not determined by hot takes, comment sections, or confident predictions of collapse.

For years, people have been saying the Adventist Church is destined to split. And yet—here we are. Still together. Sometimes tense, often argumentative, but very much intact.

First, the big-tent model has real staying power. Adventism was never built for people who agree on everything. From theology to culture to worship styles (and how long Sabbath lunch is allowed to last), disagreement has always been part of the deal. Unity with tension turns out to be far more durable than unity based on uniformity.

Second, leadership styles change. While the previous General Conference administration was widely experienced as rigid, the current one—while still emphasizing bold mission and global integration—appears more open to dialogue. That matters. Churches don’t usually split because people disagree; they split when people stop believing conversation is possible.

Third, history matters. We’ve survived far deeper conflicts than today’s—from 1888 to Ford, from science debates to ordination fights—and we’re still here. That doesn’t suggest fragility; it suggests resilience.

Fourth, “we’re better together” isn’t just a slogan. It’s a spiritual discipline. Staying together forces patience, humility, and growth in ways separation never does.

Add modern immigration to the mix, and Adventism today is one of the most globally and culturally diverse churches almost anywhere you go. That diversity guarantees uncomfortable conversations—and also makes permanent fracture far less likely.

Yes, splinter groups will happen. They always have. But that’s not the same thing as institutional collapse.

The Adventist future is not a dramatic breakup. It’s something harder and more hopeful: an awkward, occasionally bickering, globally diverse unity—held together by mission, history, and a God who’s clearly not done with us yet.

❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️

If you’re tired of breakup predictions and still believe Adventism is better together—even when it’s awkward, loud, and a little unhinged—BarelyAdventist exists for you. We use humor, satire, and just enough irreverence to say the quiet parts out loud without giving up on the church we love. Supporting BarelyAdventist on Patreon helps keep the jokes honest, the critiques constructive, and the big tent standing. Unity doesn’t have to be boring—but it does need backers.

❤️ Love BarelyAdventist? Support us on Patreon for as little as $1 per month

Head over to Adventist Today for current events updates, analysis and opinion on all things Adventist.

Read more

Local News