Here’s the definitive ranking of 28 vegetarian Adventist potluck staples, from the beloved to the baffling, the sweet to the slightly suspicious, and everything in between.
- Fruit Salad – The crown jewel. Sweet, innocent, and somehow everyone claims they made it first.
- Lemonade – Pink, yellow, fizzy—basically liquid childhood.
- Special K Loaf – The mysterious cereal-based miracle only Adventists can love. Crunchy, chewy, confusing, yet indispensable.
- Pineapple Upside-Down Cake – Sticky, sweet, and nostalgia in every bite.
- Jello Salad – Wobbly, neon, occasionally controversial (marshmallows optional), but always present.
- Macaroni Salad – Creamy, comforting, the unofficial “first scoop” dish.
- Haystacks – Corn chips, beans, cheese, lettuce chaos—pure potluck joy.
- Veggie Lasagna – Layered, cheesy, ambitious… and gone before the second announcements.
- Broccoli Salad – Crunchy, slightly healthy, often with raisins or nuts, usually ignored by kids.
- Green Bean Casserole – Classic, creamy, fried onions on top—the OG crowd-pleaser.
- Carrot Raisin Salad – Sweet, crunchy, divisive—but somehow everyone sneaks a forkful.
- Pancit – Noodles, veggies, subtle sophistication, and bonus points if your aunt added tofu.
- Pasta Salad – Italian dressing, colorful veggies, and elbow macaroni perfection.
- Nut Loaf – Dense, mysterious, feared, revered, and usually the subject of whispered admiration.
- Deviled Eggs – Elegant, protein-packed, and served with a wink.
- Cheese Ball – Funky, nostalgic, perfect with crackers, occasionally shaped like a hedgehog.
- Rice Salad – Ambitious, slightly exotic, and impressive when pulled off.
- Potato Salad – Safe, reliable, and everyone sneaks seconds.
- Dinner Rolls & Butter – Essential carbs, never optional.
- Hummus & Veggie Tray – Modern, crunchy, often ignored by kids but secretly appreciated by adults.
- Pumpkin Bread – Seasonal, aromatic, and instant comfort.
- Chocolate Cake – Emotional support food, disappears faster than you can say “amen.”
- Brownies – Fudgy, rich, sometimes nutty, universally adored.
- Pineapple Cheese Spread – Sweet-savory cult favorite. Don’t question it.
- Popcorn Balls – Sticky, sweet, and nostalgic—mostly for the brave.
- Bean Salad – Tangy, protein-packed, and perfect for those trying to eat “healthy-ish.”
- Chocolate Chip Cookies – Humble, dependable, universally loved.
- Rice Krispie Treats – Tiny squares of childhood bliss, optional marshmallow-induced toothache included.
❤️ Love BarelyAdventist? Support us on Patreon for as little as $1 per month
